Mabinogi World Wiki is brought to you by Coty C., 808idiotz, our other patrons, and contributors like you!!
Want to make the wiki better? Contribute towards getting larger projects done on our Patreon!
Use Party Healing on 3 or more people in Critical condition.
That's not what I was saying. I was saying that if you try to heal someone who cannot be healed any further due to wounds, you will not receive training, even if they are under 20%. The fact that wounds and hp can go below 0 is a well-known fact but irrelevant to the point I was trying to make.
EDIT: After rereading a bit of this, I realized that we may be arguing over completely different points. The point I'm arguing against right now is "the requirement is not only 20% of hp, but also a net % hp loss between heals". I agree that wounding does not affect what counts as 20%.
Ah ok. I see. Well. I have proven for myself that my statements hold true, so if anyone would like to disprove me, I ask for video or pictures showing that I am incorrect. This, of course, is impossible. So, I would like to go ahead and add my tip to the wiki. However, I feel if I do so, someone will simply delete my addition because they "think" I'm incorrect without proof to back their statement up. So, if anyone else would like to test these theories, I would appreciate the support.
I feel like your theory is too complicated, but if you have a simple easy-to-understand way to word what you want to say on the main page, you may as well add it. If someone removes it without explanation, you can always ask them for counter-evidence on their user talk page.
I finally realized I did not read the first post carefully enough. I now fully understand the test you were conducting and the kind of extra information you are trying to add. I'm still not sure how to word it in a way that is easily understood for the general wiki reader though. I will think about it as well.
I think it will be good enough to mention in the Training section a line from Healing.
"The skill must recover HP to receive skill training (full HP as well as wounding does not count)."
The requirement is almost the same, so I shall reword it a bit. This should be enough for any confused players who might be trying to train party heal.