Broken?

Is the map outdated, is this quest line broken, or am I incredibly stupid and not doing it right? I keep finding Whistling Rocks and playing either D or F (don't have my third bottle) and nothing happens with my quest.

I did this last week with a friend and it was working fine. More than likely you are not finding the right rocks. I didn't use the map though, so I can't say much about that. You don't have to find them in order.

Oooh ok. Should we remove the map since it seems outdated? Or can we get someone to confirm it's outdated?

If it feels outdated, someone would have to run through and go to majority of the points on the map to prove it is. I will admit on thing about the map, the black and gray is hard to differentiate :x.