Change of training requirements for r4, possibly other ranks

I noticed in game that there's a discrepancy between the listed requirements for r4 Elf training and what my game requirements are. The skill seems to have been made easier to train, but I don't know if that affects other ranks as well or for any other races. I put in question marks mainly because I honestly don't know how to remove the training requirement from the other two sections for humans and giants, if that change could be made by another person that would be helpful.

If you are willing to do the work, here is a dump that you can parse through.

Base

6565 add(1,20,"Attack an enemy.");\nadd(3,10,"Defeat an enemy.");\nadd(10,2,"Counterattack with Windmill.");\nadd(30,1,"Attack several enemies.",false);\nadd(50,1,"Defeat several enemies.",false);

6566 add(0.5,30,"Attack an enemy.");\nadd(1.5,20,"Defeat an enemy.");\nadd(1,20,"Attack a similar-ranked enemy.");\nadd(3,10,"Defeat a similar ranked enemy.");\nadd(10,5,"Defeat a powerful enemy.");\nadd(10,2,"Counterattack with Windmill.");\nadd(30,1,"Attack several enemies of similar level.",false);\nadd(50,1,"Defeat several enemies of similar level.",false);

6567 add(0.2,30,"Attack an enemy.");\nadd(0.5,20,"Defeat an enemy.");\nadd(1,30,"Attack a similar-ranked enemy.");\nadd(2,30,"Defeat a similar ranked enemy.");\nadd(8,5,"Defeat a powerful enemy.");\nadd(8,2,"Counterattack with Windmill.");\nadd(30,1,"Attack several powerful enemies.",false);\nadd(50,1,"Defeat several enemies of similar level.",false);

6568 add(0.3, 128, Attack a similar-ranked enemy.);\nadd(0.6, 64, Defeat a similar ranked enemy.);\nadd(2.5, 32, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(3, 32, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(2.5, 3, Counterattack with Windmill.);\nadd(10, 2, Attack several powerful enemies., false);\nadd(25, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies., false);

6569 add(0.06, 320, Attack a similar-ranked enemy.);\nadd(0.3, 160, Defeat a similar ranked enemy.);\nadd(1, 100, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(1.8, 50, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(1, 3, Counterattack with Windmill.);\nadd(9, 2, Attack several powerful enemies., false);\nadd(15, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies., false);

6570 add(0.2, 300, Defeat a similar ranked enemy.);\nadd(0.6, 160, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(1.2, 100, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(1, 3, Counterattack with Windmill.);\nadd(6, 2, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(10, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6571 add(0.05, 600, Defeat a similar ranked enemy.);\nadd(0.25, 400, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.5, 200, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.5, 4, Counterattack with Windmill.);\nadd(3.5, 2, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(7.5, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6572 add(0.05, 1000, Defeat a similar ranked enemy.);\nadd(0.1, 600, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.25, 400, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(1, 100, Defeat a boss-level enemy.);\nadd(0.5, 4, Counterattack with Windmill.);\nadd(3.5, 2, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(7.5, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6573 add(0.025, 2000, Defeat a similar ranked enemy.);\nadd(0.05, 1000, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.1, 1000, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.5, 200, Defeat a boss-level enemy.);\nadd(1.5, 4, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(5, 4, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6574 add(0.025, 2000, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.05, 2000, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.25, 300, Defeat a boss-level enemy.);\nadd(1, 10, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(2.5, 10, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6575 add(0.01, 3000, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.02, 3000, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.15, 450, Defeat a boss-level enemy.);\nadd(0.65, 15, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(1.65, 15, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6576 add(0.01, 3000, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.01, 3000, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.06, 450, Defeat a boss-level enemy.);\nadd(0.3, 40, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(1, 30, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6577 add(0.01, 3000, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.01, 3000, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.03, 1500, Defeat a boss-level enemy.);\nadd(0.3, 40, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(1, 30, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6578 add(0.005, 4800, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.005, 4800, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.025, 2000, Defeat a boss-level enemy.);\nadd(0.25, 48, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(0.75, 40, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

6579 add(0.005, 4800, Defeat a powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.005, 4800, Defeat a very powerful enemy.);\nadd(0.025, 2000, Defeat a boss-level enemy.);\nadd(0.25, 48, Attack several powerful enemies.);\nadd(0.75, 40, Defeat several powerful enemies.);

Elf

7720 add(1,20,"Attack an enemy");\nadd(3,10,"Defeat an enemy");\nadd(10,2,"Counterattack with Windmill");\nadd(20,1,"Attack several enemies",false);\nadd(30,1,"Defeat several enemies",false);

7721 add(0.5,30,"Attack an enemy");\nadd(1.5,20,"Defeat an enemy");\nadd(1,20,"Attack a similar-ranked enemy");\nadd(3,10,"Defeat a similar ranked enemy");\nadd(10,5,"Defeat a powerful enemy");\nadd(10,2,"Counterattack with Windmill");\nadd(20,1,"Attack several enemies of similar level",false);\nadd(30,1,"Defeat several enemies of similar level",false

7722 add(0.2,30,"Attack an enemy");\nadd(0.5,20,"Defeat an enemy");\nadd(1,30,"Attack a similar-ranked enemy");\nadd(2,30,"Defeat a similar ranked enemy");\nadd(8,5,"Defeat a powerful enemy");\nadd(8,2,"Counterattack with Windmill");\nadd(20,1,"Attack several powerful enemies",false);\nadd(30,1,"Defeat several enemies of similar level",false);

7723 add(0.3, 128, Attack a similar-ranked enemy);\nadd(0.6, 64, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(2.5, 32, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(3, 32, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(2.5, 3, Counterattack with Windmill);\nadd(5, 2, Attack several powerful enemies, false);\nadd(20, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies, false);

7724 add(0.06, 320, Attack a similar-ranked enemy);\nadd(0.3, 160, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(1, 100, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(1.8, 50, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(1, 3, Counterattack with Windmill);\nadd(5, 2, Attack several powerful enemies, false);\nadd(10, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies, false);

7725 add(0.2, 300, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(0.6, 160, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(1.2, 100, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(1, 3, Counterattack with Windmill);\nadd(5, 2, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(8, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7726 add(0.05, 600, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(0.25, 400, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.5, 200, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.5, 4, Counterattack with Windmill);\nadd(3, 2, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(5, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7727 add(0.05, 1000, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(0.1, 600, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.25, 400, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(1, 80, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.5, 4, Counterattack with Windmill);\nadd(3.5, 2, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(7.5, 2, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7728 add(0.025, 2000, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(0.05, 1000, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.1, 1000, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.5, 160, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(1.5, 4, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(5, 4, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7729 add(0.025, 2000, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.05, 2000, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.25, 200, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(1, 10, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(2.5, 10, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7730 add(0.01, 3000, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.02, 3000, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.15, 300, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.65, 15, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(1.65, 15, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7731 add(0.01, 3000, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.01, 3000, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.06, 400, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.3, 40, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(1, 30, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7732 add(0.01, 3000, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.01, 3000, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.03, 1200, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.3, 40, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(1, 30, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7733 add(0.005, 4800, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.005, 4800, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.025, 1500, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.25, 48, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(0.75, 40, Defeat several powerful enemies);

7734 add(0.005, 5000, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.005, 5000, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.025, 2400, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.25, 50, Attack several powerful enemies);\nadd(0.75, 50, Defeat several powerful enemies);

Giant

8000 add(1,50,"Attack an enemy");\nadd(5,10,"Defeat an enemy");\nadd(10,2,"Use the Windmill to counter");\nadd(30,1,"Attack multiple enemies",false);\nadd(50,1,"Successfully defeat multiple enemies",false);

8001 add(0.5,80,"Attack an enemy");\nadd(2.5,15,"Defeat an enemy");\nadd(2,15,"Attack a similar ranked enemy");\nadd(5,4,"Defeat a similar ranked enemy");\nadd(10,10,"Defeat a powerful enemy");\nadd(8,2,"Use the Windmill to counter");\nadd(20,1,"Attack multiple similar ranked enemies",false);\nadd(40,1,"Defeat multiple similar ranked enemies",false);

8002 add(0.1,250,"Attack an enemy");\nadd(1,25,"Defeat an enemy");\nadd(1.5,20,"Attack a similar ranked enemy");\nadd(3,6,"Defeat a similar ranked enemy");\nadd(5,25,"Defeat a powerful enemy");\nadd(6,3,"Use the Windmill to counter");\nadd(15,1,"Attack multiple powerful enemies",false);\nadd(30,1,"Defeat multiple similar ranked enemies",false);

8003 add(1, 30, Attack a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(2, 10, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(3, 35, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(5, 24, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(4, 5, Use the Windmill to counter);\nadd(10, 2, Attack multiple powerful enemies, false);\nadd(20, 2, Defeat multiple powerful enemies, false);

8004 add(0.6, 60, Attack a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(1.5, 20, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(2, 60, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(3, 40, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(3, 6, Use the Windmill to counter);\nadd(8, 2, Attack multiple powerful enemies, false);\nadd(15, 2, Defeat multiple powerful enemies, false);

8005 add(1, 80, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(1.5, 80, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(2, 60, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(2, 10, Use the Windmill to counter);\nadd(5, 2, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(10, 2, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8006 add(0.6, 100, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(1, 50, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(1.5, 80, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(1.5, 6, Use the Windmill to counter);\nadd(4, 2, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(8, 2, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8007 add(0.3, 200, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(0.6, 100, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(1, 120, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(10, 3, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(1, 10, Use the Windmill to counter);\nadd(3, 4, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(6, 2, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8008 add(0.1, 500, Defeat a similar ranked enemy);\nadd(0.3, 170, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.6, 200, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(5, 6, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(2, 8, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(4, 4, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8009 add(0.1, 500, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.3, 400, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(3, 10, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(1, 10, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(2, 10, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8010 add(0.08, 400, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.1, 300, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(1, 50, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.9, 15, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(1.8, 15, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8011 add(0.06, 400, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.08, 300, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.5, 100, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.8, 10, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(1.6, 10, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8012 add(0.04, 600, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.06, 400, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.1, 500, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.7, 16, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(1.4, 12, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8013 add(0.02, 1300, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.04, 600, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.07, 700, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.6, 20, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(1.2, 16, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

8014 add(0.01, 2500, Defeat a powerful enemy);\nadd(0.02, 1250, Defeat a very powerful enemy);\nadd(0.05, 1000, Defeat a Boss-level enemy);\nadd(0.5, 40, Attack multiple powerful enemies);\nadd(1, 20, Defeat multiple powerful enemies);

Farix, that dump is wrong.

See here: http://img440.imageshack.us/img440/4102/mabinogi20120428004.jpg

Just got to r4 WM myself. They added a 'defeat an enemy' requirement that's not in that dump of yours. It works as advertised, too, as you can see in my screenshot.

Herp. Looks like that screen got resized.

So far, I know there is:

R4: Defeat an enemy, +0.06, 400

R3: Defeat an enemy, +0.04, 600

That is for giants, of course.

For Elves, rank 5 - 3 (Most likely 1) do NOT have a plain "Defeat an enemy" requirements. I'm not sure who added that as one of the requirements but it sure doesn't belong.

It was changed, it USED to have it.

Wouldn't it be better to have any of those that 'must' be listed (due to giants needing it (?)) set to 0.00? Just seems a bit misleading with "??", like it's there, but needs to be filled in by anyone who knows the training requirements.