Hey

"has the blood of Lugh Lavada" refers to the Demigod transformation/Elatha's Soul. I guess that shouldn't be on that list because their relationship is a bit iffy, but even so, these is no possible reason for removing those NPCs from the Milletian list.

i dont know who the idiot that started the idea that Elatha is the son.

plus Lugh, and other NPCs arent milletiian...

dragons lived in Erinn before gods.

idk why three warrios and ferghus is milletian. o.o

Mari/Nao is on there because she has access to the soul stream and rebirth. Tarlach and Ruairi are not on that list.

Aton Cimeni made Erinn, there is no way dragons lived there before it existed. Adniel and Cromm Cruaich at some point in the storyline said they were not from Erinn as well.

Lugh/Morgant claimed to be a Milletian, and it is also stated in Tarlach's record.

Tin and Fleta have been reborn a few times, as stated by tin.

Ferghus is from the world of Vindictus, plus he also has access to the soul stream.

Dougal is from the world of Vindictus but was summoned to Erinn, his original body, the Glas, was separated from his soul. His soul became Dougal (Added Soul Phenomenon).

Any questions?

Post Script: And I do hate that Lugh-Elatha-Neamhain-Triona theory, it has no solid evidence.

didnt Lugh claimed to be human, not miletian? sorry if im wrong.

adniel and cromm cruaich is not milletian because they came as their own accord and conquered Iria before Neamhain sealed them in Zardine.

Tin and Fleta and Nao is what they called "길잡이 or guide-post" (i only know the word in korean, but not in English) and is blessed by deity to guide Milletian.

Ferghus.. sigh.... as mentioned by DevCAT, vindictus is parallel world to mabinogi and that was april fools event.... so you cant realy put him as milletian.

same with Dougal.

Dougal claims to be a Milletian in G1, so he is staying. I will remove Ferghus. =S As for Tin, Fleta, and Nao, idk... How exactly does Fleta guide us in any way? Milletians do not have to be summoned, and conquering Iria has nothing to do with this. And one can be both Human and Milletian, they can also be an Elf, Dragon, Giant, Glas, anything really. Milletian is not a species.

isnt the definition of milletian a living soul called upon Erinn by Morrighan?

and idk about Fleta either ;; just thinking since Tin is Fleta's aunt so she must be mysterious blah blah blah.

and did Lugh specifically said he was Milletian? i dun remember C1 very much.

as for Glas, it is one of fallen gods.

Technically it is Nao, but there have been Milletians before Mari became Nao (Lugh Lavada [They Fight him in a Rabbie RP]). Yes, Lugh is no doubt a Milletian. And Morgant claimed to be Lugh in G3, I believe. And either way, Glas is not from Erinn. He may be a god of another world, but he is not from Erinn.

i mean give me the quote where morgant says he is milletian. im kind of interested.

Here is a quote from Tarlach's record, "According to the Knight of Light, who is a Milletian himself." Tarlach's Record#Questions about the Perception of Time

thats you :P

since its after you became the knight of the light, tarlach is using the info given by you.

i dont think Tarlach was old enough since Second Moitura ended 20~30 yrs ago.

According to the Knight of Light and other Milletians, this occurs across the board amongst all Tuatha Dé Dananns of Erinn. If that is the case, it is unlikely that this is happening as a result of mere forgetfulness

According to the Knight of Light, who is a Milletian himself, several decades have passed since Milletians have first arrived in Erinn. But to my knowledge, from the perspective of a Tuatha Dé Danann, Milletians arrived in Erinn no more than a few years back

That may be debatable, but "the knight of light" is a term only used in NA to refer to "Lugh the Knight of Light".

knight of light is another term for "true" paladin like the definition of the keyword: knight of light.

The point is, he is referring to Lugh Lavada, not the player.

you know, i kind of like this debate. Its so fun 8D im so glad im having it with you cuz last time i had one, that guy was keep dissing and continued to speak nonsense and didnt provided reason.....

he said "returned" knight of light.

as the returned, he means the power.

if he was stating Lugh, he wouldnt state "returned" but stated "according to the record left by Lugh"

What could "returned" mean when referring to the player whom never left?

returned as in the power.

for example: lord of the ring: return of the king.

Aragon was a heir and he regained his throne. he never left the kingdom though.

g8: dragons say Golden dragon shall return. however, Adniel is a new born dragon.

he is referring to the status/power rather than a person.

This still does not prove that he is referring to the player or Lugh Lavada.

there were only two knight of light: Lugh and You.

its impossible for Lugh to return so only milletian makes sense.

When is the player ever referred to as the knight of light? Savior of the Goddess and Savior of Erinn Maybe, but Knight of Light?...

owo g2 and g3

g2, price say when tabharta smashed you when you transform, "nuu knight of light is invincible~" or sumthing like taht

g3, eavan say, "even though you are knight of light,,,,, blah blah blah

whole storyline of g2 is how you become knight of light. o.o

Yes, but do they actually call you the knight of light? Verbatim?

Dangit, I just went through that part of G3, where you need the fomor robe and Eaven refuses to give it to you. She does refer to you as the knight of light, but ignores that fact and continues to refuse to give it to you.

so Lugh nao glas ferghus tin fleta dougal dragons

are out of option. am i correct?

Lugh/Morgant is still being discussed. Glas, Dougal, Cromm, and Adniel are Milletians, there is proof for them in G1, G8, and maybe G3. Tin, Fleta, and Nao idk about, where does it say that they are "guide-post"? I still do not see how the player could have returned.

  returned as in the power. 

for example: lord of the ring: return of the king.

Aragon was a heir and he regained his throne. he never left the kingdom though.

g8: dragons say Golden dragon shall return. however, Adniel is a new born dragon.

he is referring to the status/power rather than a person.

therefore, tarlach record is refering to you.

so Lugh isnt Milletian.

just because they are from the other world doesnt mean they are milletian.

All Tuath Danan are from other world too.

so that proves dragon, glas, dougal isnt milltan.

and the detail about Tin used to be in NPC guide in mabi web. he even says, "is all Milletian like that...?" if you talk to him somehow.

Wait, when does it ever say Tuatha Danann are from other worlds? And yes, being originally from another world does make you a Milletian. And Adniel is not a newborn. He was reborn. That specific Gold Dragon existed before. His personality may be different (him being good or evil), but that does not mean he is a different dragon. All Gold Dragons are the same person. I agree, Lugh/Morgant is not a Milletian, so I will remove him. However, what you have said still doesn't explain how the Milletian "returned". Can you get some proof of Tin and the other Guide posts in NA? Something true in another server may not be true in NA. For example, Nekojima's storyline does not apply in NA. And I still need some more solid proof of KR's Guide Posts.

i seriously cannot provide you with proof of Tin except his quote "is all Milletian like that...?" since KR site was revamped after c3 update.

and the beginning of the tarlach record stats that tuatha danann are from other world.

 These Milletians are much different from our people, Tuatha Dé Dananns, Descendants of Dannu. According to legend, our people, Tuatha Dé Dananns, did not originate from Erinn either so it is not really all that strange for a new ethnic group to migrate to Erinn afterall. We are very different overall, and are definitely of a different ethnic group. 

and isnt the requirement for milletian

from another world and came with help from Nao/Morrrighan?

Keyword "legend". Tarlach does not know for sure himself. Legends are merely glorified rumors.

Legend (Dictionary.com) - a nonhistorical or unverifiable story handed down by tradition from earlier times and popularly accepted as historical.

anyhow, main point is the definition of milletian.

if the definition is "from another world", then feel free to include dragon, glad, and dougal.

however, if it is from another world and came with help from Nao/Morrrighan, then dragon,glas and dougal must be ommiteed.

It is "From the Stars". And it isn't necessarily with the help with Nao and Morrighan since the Glas came to Erinn with the help of the Fomorians. Lugh, Morgant, and Ferghus are removed. There is no proof on Guide Posts in NA so they will remain. Cromm, Adniel, Glas, and Dougal will also remain.

bu8t Dougal and Glas: they dont get into this: "If one has one or all of the following abilities, then he or she is considered a Milletian as long as they are not native to Erinn:

Ability to be reborn. Fast perception of time. Milletian Elves do not share their memories with Memory Tower in Filia. All Milletians experience these symptoms:

Have memories of them with Tuatha de Dananns that slowly fade away. Ability to enter and leave Erinn's Soul Stream."

so they must be out.

as for Mari/Nao, she is Tuath Dannan >.>

What is your proof on Mari/Nao? Another thing is that Nao never forgets the player, that means she is not a Tuatha Danann. And I'll fix that Error. They can only Enter Erinn's Soul Stream when in Erinn. Let me make a map to show what I mean. I'll update this post in a moment.

UPDATE:

This is basically how the worlds work. Erinn's Soul Stream is where Nao is. Erinn Soul Stream acts as a gateway between Erinn and other Soul Streams. Glas/Dougal was summoned to Tir Na Nog while he was in another world. Tir Na Nog is connected to Erinn, but not directly connected any Soul Stream. Therefore, he would have to first travel to Erinn to enter Erinn's Soul Stream without otherwise being summoned.

the "body" dugald lived in the other world since he was little. the "soul" came to the being by Edith Soul or sumthing like that, which means skipping Soul Stream

The body Dougal had in Other World was the Glas. When he was summoned to Tir Na Nog, his body became soulless and controlled by the Fomors. Whereas his soul, with the Added Soul Phenomenon, took a new human-form, that is the Duncan-like body. I don't know what Edith Soul is, but he did skip Soul Stream. That is why I wrote a 1-way line on the map. As I said before, something true in Korea may not be true in Japan, United States, or China. Perhaps we are both right. Lets say the Korean->English translation for G1 says a different thing than the original Korean. That may also be a cause for this. As far as I am concerned, based on NA, Dougal is a Milletian is no such thing (or mention) of Guide-Posts.

nope. KR and NA is the EXACT copy.

Glas used to be a god but then it was punished by the gods for some unknown reason.

then Fomorian started to recreate a body for Glas from the bones of giant and (was it mythril or adamantium?) in Other World.

after it finished, fomorian called the Glas's soul from the world of gods.

however, something went wrong and the body gained life, but the soul of Glas went into the dying human living in Other World (it was previously conquered by fomorian.)

so Dougal or Glas's soul was pissed at fomorian for forcing him to come to the barren world ask you to destroy his body so that he may be at rest again.

so Dougal/Glas cannot be milletian.......

i wont say anything about guide-post since i cannot provide you with strong fact and im starting to doubt my memories :P

First of all, there is no mention of Glas being a god in NA. Second of all, he might have possessed a Tir Na Nog human, I am not sure about that part. Third of all, the bones had to be of giants, by giants they meant other Glases, but they used the word Giant. (They didn't think they would at Giants at the time.) And if you do not have enough bones to form the skeletal frame, you need to create it out of Adamantium, not Mythril. There is not enough Adamantium in Erinn to create a complete skeletal frame. And yes, being from another world, "from the stars", does make you a Fomor. Falias is in Erinn so the Erinn's Gods are not Milletians. And yes, they try to translate it close to Korea, but it usually, back at the time of C1, was translated into something slightly different. (Especially the in-game books.) G9-G14 is normally translated correctly, with the exception of Korean humor and added emphasis.