Too much speculation and personal opinion

To me, keeping a list to stuff that qualifies beyond reasonable doubt is nice, crisp, and clean, but sometimes ends up too short for a distinct mention and doesn't usually allow for a quick peek at stuff that can be seen beyond the original point (which is the main issue I have).

The reverse would get really hard to manage when it gets long, but I find it interesting to see what goes on there and more importantly it can allow for interconnectivity with related facts. (And I thought that was a wiki's strength? The easy internal links?)

And I did kinda use the word "list" arbitrarily - it doesn't just have to be like shopping lists that require only the name, I did mean stuff more like a list that contains explanations/exposition, sublists, further readings. And from the title of "Gods", I'd think this page belongs more dominantly to the latter category.

Forums format probably is easier to read, though I still think that if we can communicate on the wiki it's better to use it.