Valid Recipe

What do you mean by valid recipe? I just tried using both salt and garlic as a 3rd ingredient and produced this dish.

The recipe hasn't changed at all (iirc it even shows three ingredients in its tooltip), and other than Rush of Love quests don't care about the food quality or how they were made.

Well you can only get the fish at doki doki and I have discovered that you only need those two ingredients. I don't appreciate people deleting my contributions. I wouldn't add something willy nilly if it wasn't true. :|

People find the ingredient listing CONFUSING. There are like 3 different possible recipes. Lets simplify it.

That doesn't invalidate the other method though. I've known about two ingredients as in the discussion below, but I've always used a third ingredient regardless. It's all preference.

Calling the two ingredient method the "only" valid method and "there is no 3rd ingredient" is false.

Also how is the ingredient listing confusing? There's a semicolon to separate the two methods. You could separate it using bullet listings, but I don't see how it's confusing at all.

I can't, there is no edit link.

You don't need a third ingredient.

I think the goal of the recipes should be "what gets you 5-star". Excluding the third ingredient may not provide sufficient error for food waste, but unless you can 4 or 5-star the two ingredient recipe it should remain as a side note that the dish can be produced without garlic or salt.

Edit: apparently the wiki has already had this discussion a few inches down 2 years ago might be best to do nothing owo

I have achieved 4 star dishes using only tuna and onions.