Talk:Fishing Event (2012)

Can anyone actually confirm they have obtained; Grim Reaper Robe, (and Nexon stated Guardian Souls stone?)

via Photographic evidence of some sort? or possibly confirmation from KR,JP, etc wiki's that state the item's existence? i just want the robe @_@...

There is no item in data called Guardian Soul Stone, most likely referring to Nao Soul Stone. And of course the robe exists in other servers, but prize lists vary between servers.

Although Nao Stones are already on the list..

so there is a grim reaper robe?

yes, it is one of the design contest winner robes if I am not mistaken.

Yeah its a design contest winner, i just wanted to know if it actually existed in NA, have not seen anyone yet. ty then

well its only been less than a day, give it at least 2 or 3 before we question its legitimacy.

http://mabinogi.nexon.net/event/contest/design-contest-winners.html

first robe in the robe tab.

someone posted a picture, all good

This is the first time I'm replying to a talk page on the wiki so I hope I'm doing it right...

The Grim Reaper robe has been confirmed to come from Bingo. I sort of removed it from the fishing event because I do not think it comes from this. Every robe so far obtained (including posts on nexon forum) claim that they got it from Bingo. Sorry if I removed it in error, although I don't see it coming from two events going on at the same time.

I am wondering the same thing. I have been fishing upwards of 16 hours a day since the event started and have yet to see one, or hear of anyone else fishing one up.

One of my guildies got the robe from the fishing event, either the rate of it being fished up is rare, or everyone's just unlucky.

Please quit removing the grim reaper's robe from the reward list, it's confirmed that the robe is a reward from both the Bingo and the fishing events.

Ok this is starting to get incredibly annoying... compromise for god's sake.

• how about we Bold the grim reaper in the fishing event rewards list? outlining it is a rare find in fishing than it it from bingo.

if not

• stop adding grim reapers robe because it is annoying the hell out of people in the forums who doubt it's legitimacy...
• reasoning : whilst taking in mind that since Nexon outlined certain items, Fairy Feather Bow for example are a notable and confirmed fishing drop, this implies that Grim Reaper Robe does NOT exist in fishing, OR it is an extremely rare fished object implied by, and much more!.

Doesn't really imply that it doesn't exist in the fishing event just because it's not listed in nexon's post.

i quote.. myself "OR it is an extremely rare fished object",

I don't see the event description matching anything about potions, which are not extremely rare whatsoever.

and this "Guardian Soul Stone" item doesnt even exist in the database. So it's listed, but also doesn't come from the event.

According to many eye-witnesses, and those who took actual pics of themselves actually using the robes, it does come from both events.

I removed it again and I will continue to remove it because you're literally making stuff up.

Read page 16 on "Where's the grim reaper's Robe?" by Morbious on the General forum of the Mabinogi Nexon Forums. He officially confirmed it with Sabina today that the Grim Reaper Robe does NOT come from the fishing event. "Ok, I got clarification. The robe is not currently available from the fishing event."

Now stop ruining the integrity of the wiki and making everyone confused. I was being nice the first time but every single person on test and on the real servers who got the robe knew it was from Bingo, except apparently your friend and "many eye witnesses".

Edit: Sorry for the hostility, I don't mean it that way, I just woke up when I wrote this. But it is a bit frustrating to me because of how many people it confused.

Thank you. Now I can stop worrying about fishing so much trying to find it.

Just to back you up there. The Whole post for those not bothered to go to the Forums. btw i added the feather bow back to the list. Ok, I got clarification. The robe is not currently available from the fishing event. (there was an is between robe and through which was confusing)

It IS a reward in the bingo event.

The Fairy Bow is in the fishing event.

Nao stones are still in the event.

Guardian stones were removed.

The devCAT hat is from fishing.

The feather sword is from bingo event.

Sorry for the confusion yesterday, but this should clear up some questions.

Thanks for that. Hopefully that settles this crap.

The Cotton Candy from this event has special effects when eaten. How should we organize this?

oh shit woah, I didnt even notice xD Indigo gives berserk o.o I would just add it into an extra section on the cotton candy page, and put a note on fishing event page.

I added a section in cotton candy for the effects. I can't add in most of them yet, but i set it all up.

I think we should have a seperate page or simply list the effects on the event page.

why wouldn't we list the effect on the page of the item itself though.

Since there are multiple versions of the items given out by different events and have different corresponding effects.
EDIT:Actually I'm pretty sure they're the same as Cotton Candy (Children's Day) in exception to the name.

The children's day cotton candies were renamed in the last update to itemdb so that they no longer say "Children's Day"

So yeah they are the same.

So, should we move the details to the "Children's Day" version or keep it as it is?

Maybe I am missing it, but where do we get more bait?

Walter.