Mini-game woes.

I've noticed that the best results (centered hits) come not from hitting the bar at the fullest possible amount, but from clicking between the green bar "limits" (I.E. half-full green bar). I don't know if I'm making myself clear enough, english is not my native language. Anyway, if anyone can help me test this theory, feel free to do so.

I once heard that there are two times where it's best, when it hits green and when it's full.

I've tried those, but my "hit" never lands in the middle (I always position my cursor exactly where it should be), always to one side or the other. Still, I'll be experimenting on my own.

Because it's random based on your blacksmithing rank.

If the hits were to be exactly where you clicked it. You would be making X-Graded items left and right.

No, no. What I meant is, that when I try the points mentioned by Ikkisuki/Kevin, I never get a good hit. But when I try exactly between those points, my hit will almost always land in the middle/very close to it. Still, as I said, it's just a theory, so it needs to be checked.

it's coincidence. Smithing's been around for 7 years on KR.

Would have said something if that was the case.