Mabinogi World Wiki is brought to you by Coty C., 808idiotz, our other patrons, and contributors like you!!
Keep this wiki going by contributing to our Patreon!

Dur Loss

Dur Loss

Doesn't this bow lose dur at half the rate of other bows? Well I went to edit it, and it said don't touch and make a topic on the page, so here it is.

Meru (talk)‎13:59, 31 July 2013

Why would it lose dura at half rate? o_O

͟͞ҡ͟͞ε͟͞ѵ͟͞ו͟͞͞η [͟͞т͟͞α͟͞ι͟͞κ]‎14:06, 31 July 2013
 

I don't know. Maybe because it's specifically for elves? I remember getting it tested a long time ago and was told it does lose durability at half the rate.

Meru (talk)‎14:09, 31 July 2013
 

Don't believe everything you're told.

͟͞ҡ͟͞ε͟͞ѵ͟͞ו͟͞͞η [͟͞т͟͞α͟͞ι͟͞κ]‎14:11, 31 July 2013
 

Well, when you are told by multiple people that tested it. It just seems pretty sure. I'm almost 98% sure that it does. Maybe someone here can test it.

Meru (talk)‎14:14, 31 July 2013
 

And the results are in!

  • Test: LLB vs GB Durability Loss
  • Conditions:
    • Tested on Armadillos at the outskirts of Filia
  • Tools used:
    • One (1) Durability Loss Recorder
    • Two (2) Quivers full of five hundred (500) arrows × 2 (one set for each bow)
    • One (1) newly purchased, unblessed Leather Long Bow via Meles.
    • One (1) newly purchased, unblessed Guardian Bow via Meles.
    • Newly created elf character
    • The poor lives of many armadillos who were killed in the making of this data. May they rest in peace.
  • Notes:
    • Oddly, despite using 500 arrows, both results show a bit under 500 results. Something in the game allows one to use an arrow, but not lose durability.
    • The LLB was tested first. The GB afterwards.
    • After about 200 shots using the GB, I just spammed miss range cause it was taking too long.
      • Oddly, I was about to hit monsters lightyears away from my position 5 times. SoG TRUE???
    • Don't ask me about the outlier in the LLB results. I have no idea either.
    • Data values are out of a 1000. 1000 being the true value of 1 entire durability.
      • E.g. A value of 28 = 28/1000 = 0.028 durability
  • Data:

Leather Long Bow

  • Sum: 7.516 durability lost
  • Average: 0.01575681342 durability lost/shot
  • Count: 477 values
LLB
28
21
22
27
1
18
4
12
1
15
12
4
27
18
27
22
28
4
3
16
21
22
27
19
15
10
15
19
3
21
12
4
27
24
13
13
3
25
21
27
22
25
10
10
19
4
21
12
3
4
6
10
3
3
13
4
1
10
28
28
22
20
18
12
9
30
12
3
15
13
28
28
22
15
28
6
18
10
27
19
16
13
27
10
28
18
27
18
1
27
7
1
10
21
3
21
22
15
18
12
30
30
22
1
3
27
7
6
21
15
21
19
16
22
3
9
18
10
24
30
18
18
12
27
12
30
13
22
22
21
28
19
16
21
24
15
19
7
19
3
24
4
9
25
18
3
4
27
6
21
16
30
15
13
13
4
12
4
13
9
30
16
1
18
6
24
16
3
22
16
19
21
13
9
15
27
13
10
3
1
21
16
19
7
27
21
3
18
1
21
6
6
28
30
3
12
12
10
6
27
4
22
6
4
21
10
16
7
4
13
19
22
7
3
7
18
13
1
24
19
12
28
25
4
4
6
28
24
18
4
1
30
22
18
30
24
4
13
6
9
18
19
27
22
13
16
6
30
12
15
27
7
18
24
22
18
19
22
21
22
9
21
4
6
7
9
4
24
1
28
6
15
10
15
15
28
6
10
30
12
24
21
24
28
21
25
24
16
16
4
21
7
28
16
15
30
30
16
1
18
18
10
9
9
25
15
22
3
18
9
24
28
12
21
30
18
12
6
3
7
9
12
10
28
21
9
24
10
24
25
15
9
28
27
7
1
19
19
12
22
18
28
6
7
28
22
12
9
30
18
27
27
30
22
24
30
7
16
12
4
16
30
13
15
6
22
27
1
13
12
28
15
4
4
24
25
12
10
21
7
34
21
19
25
27
3
18
10
7
24
3
25
25
24
10
15
7
15
15
15
15
3
18
4
1
28
16
3
13
18
25
15
25
24
30
10
7
12
15
3
19
25
21
27
13
3
25
18
18
27
6
30
18
6
6
22
18
9
12
9
27
3
21
22
28
30
19
9
25
6
6
25
9
13
10
21
27
18
27
4
30
3
13
3
13
9
9
16
25
4
9
1
13
12
21
9
28

Guardian Bow

  • Sum: 7.538 durability lost
  • Average: 0.01563900415 durability lost/shot
  • Count: 482 values
GB
6
22
3
13
27
28
12
13
7
30
1
4
24
21
4
16
24
9
1
1
4
30
1
22
16
22
16
3
27
27
19
12
15
12
6
10
9
12
10
12
4
28
9
4
24
16
21
1
27
3
7
22
9
6
1
21
13
16
15
3
13
19
28
4
12
25
21
1
13
16
13
6
3
4
4
24
9
30
10
9
1
19
13
7
12
16
25
27
12
18
1
4
1
19
6
30
19
3
9
16
15
15
19
12
18
15
7
15
22
1
10
10
21
22
9
16
16
10
21
4
15
3
28
30
19
10
10
28
19
27
1
24
20
27
7
12
13
24
25
18
24
18
28
30
16
24
12
15
28
28
28
25
27
19
10
9
15
12
1
28
12
18
21
16
19
12
1
27
12
30
27
6
15
13
25
13
22
6
19
27
1
4
13
9
27
6
19
25
19
4
13
24
21
16
28
22
19
28
30
25
24
10
28
7
30
16
9
12
10
21
1
28
30
28
15
10
21
3
19
13
25
4
7
22
9
19
9
22
28
27
4
28
19
28
6
24
18
25
7
4
30
10
12
15
15
30
15
28
16
22
21
13
24
7
1
16
4
13
12
4
25
22
27
19
3
13
16
27
22
15
30
15
25
6
28
9
18
15
10
22
18
13
22
1
4
16
28
15
15
28
18
7
1
13
18
6
6
25
30
15
12
15
13
3
9
15
7
16
28
7
28
16
3
30
16
4
28
13
12
12
16
3
3
22
30
19
15
19
1
13
3
30
30
27
1
19
7
9
25
28
18
21
6
18
24
4
3
12
28
7
25
28
19
22
13
27
16
10
6
6
1
21
21
21
21
27
6
6
22
27
22
12
19
1
27
1
9
16
16
22
13
10
27
16
21
24
19
18
16
7
22
7
25
16
9
22
24
25
21
6
4
27
6
3
27
16
9
7
16
4
22
19
21
13
21
18
15
7
9
24
24
19
12
6
13
9
12
24
21
28
13
18
9
27
10
7
7
22
9
13
30
22
10
19
1
30
30
30
10
27
22
27
9
12
16
6
16
15
22
27
12
4
19
18
27
13
10
12
22
10
18
7
24
21
1
3
4
28
4
16
1
10
  • Conclusion:
    • Durability loss for bows is 0.001~0.030 per shot.
    • Missing shots consumes the same durability as hitting shots. Just wanted to make sure.
    • SOG IS TRUEEEEEE ZOMG.
    • Elf Ranged is a bitch. Thank god my main isn't one.
    • Guardian Bow does not lose half the durability of other bows.

Now, tell me again about the "tests" that the "multiple people" told you they've done.

͟͞ҡ͟͞ε͟͞ѵ͟͞ו͟͞͞η [͟͞т͟͞α͟͞ι͟͞κ]‎15:42, 31 July 2013

Do crits drain dura faster? I'm pretty sure it does.

まそっぷ ！ (talk)‎15:55, 31 July 2013
 

No clue, but I doubt it. :l There'd probably be more outlier values if it did. Seeing as there's only one value above 0.030, I don't think crits drain more.

͟͞ҡ͟͞ε͟͞ѵ͟͞ו͟͞͞η [͟͞т͟͞α͟͞ι͟͞κ]‎15:57, 31 July 2013
 
Edited by author.
Last edit: 16:05, 31 July 2013

No it doesn't. I just did a crit hit and compared it witha regular throw. though odd thing is, I lost more dura on a normal throw than a crit...weird. probably has something to with the tick. Actually it was the distance.

まそっぷ ！ (talk)‎16:03, 31 July 2013

.002 more.

まそっぷ ！ (talk)‎16:05, 31 July 2013

Then it was probably just randomly higher..? Dura loss is not fixed (except for production and gathering). o-o

͟͞ҡ͟͞ε͟͞ѵ͟͞ו͟͞͞η [͟͞т͟͞α͟͞ι͟͞κ]‎16:06, 31 July 2013
 

Probably. I don't even know. I'm not putting up with throwing attack anymore lol...I'm rank 3 and dam it is hard to sit all day and wait 7 seconds a throw...I still have 9733 Javelins to get rid of. They were on sale for 3K a piece, and I had 12000 LOL...

まそっぷ ！ (talk)‎16:09, 31 July 2013
 
 
 

Where thell did you read that? It's the same amount of dura lost, regardless of race.

まそっぷ ！ (talk)‎15:54, 31 July 2013
 

Well that is strange I just did a test too with someone with a durability mod. The results we got was that it lost about 25% less durability than a normal long bow. 0.284 total loss for Guardian and .373 total loss for long bow. We did 10 magnums and 10 normal shots with both bows and with both arrows hitting the monster.

Meru (talk)‎16:19, 31 July 2013

With such a small data sample, and such a large dura loss variation (0.030~0.001), you can't even call your test a test...

͟͞ҡ͟͞ε͟͞ѵ͟͞ו͟͞͞η [͟͞т͟͞α͟͞ι͟͞κ]‎16:25, 31 July 2013
 

YOu need at least 1000 shots.

まそっぷ ！ (talk)‎16:36, 31 July 2013
 
 
Retrieved from "https://wiki.mabinogiworld.com/view/Thread:Talk:Guardian_Bow/Dur_Loss#Dur_Loss_27574"