So...between G3 and...G16,

She died...? Then again, she was human, not a Milletian.

Another thing's bothering me...According to Cichol, she died "Long ago"

what do you think he meant by that...?

There was another timing consistency, too...Owen commented that Lugh's deeds were from hundreds of years ago, though Tarlach only mentions it as "a few years a go" (in his book about Milletians, I think).

Then there's the problem of both Triona and Bella being Macha...Bella existed before Triona, but also existed after Triona dies in G3...that was a killer plot twist, but it's still kinda poorly narrated...

I got a feeling a Time Paradox is involved...and a season/sidequest/Mainstream quest chain will appear to explain a lot of things...

Wait wait, what happened?

I only heard from other sources that Triona died and Bella played mind tricks on Lugh to make him think she's Triona.

The problem is the Time consistency like Akira said :c

But you are correct that she was indeed brainwashed Lugh into thinking that. As far as Triona dying, the time frame of when she died is rather...puzzling.

Remind me again what's a time paradox...

...It's when you do something...but it wasn't suppose to happen, and it messes up the time line...

You know what, scratch what I said about the Time Paradox...though technically...Bella may have done something that cause all of this to Happen...Her Journal is...quite conspicuous as it is extremely old. Not to mention it cuts off at the best part :l

What does Bella's journal say?

In short, Tir Na Nog died because of Morrighan...(illegible)...She watches shakespeare under Morrighan's orders...(illegible)...Morrighan wants Tir Na Nog to be saved...something about Milletians ignoring Cichol's warnings and Cichol must (cut off right there)

I really wanted to know what Cichol was gonna do D:

Oh ya, she might have fallen in love with Shakespeare, which may have cause the entire mess to happen o-o

I think Bella did have feelings, since she showed signs of remorse and regret.

Anyway, Triona dying somewhere in between the 13 Gens is a serious plot hole...

...... I believe this is problem of..

• Director's story error.
• Invoving Shakespeare in the story line (G13~G16)
• G3 storyline still have some unexplained plots. There is a rumor... In Korea, the G3 storyline was updated with the Mabinogi's 1st Anniversary. But they suppose to scheduled with different date. Somehow, G3 storyline was quickly created than other privious generations.

• G16 storyline has a many bugs or errors in both story line and the game play.

Conclusion: DevCAT made a old mainstream characters into the minor characters.

Ok... I know it's been 3 month that I wrote this reply.

There's been a rumor that Triona's death is caused by the process of Lia Fail. We know that Ruairi destroyed Lia Fail. But it was too much for Triona's body to handle this process. That might explains why she did not say anything at the end of G3, but leave with her father.

Keyword, rumor. Is there any actual evidence to this hypothesis?

I am not sure if I can write this, because it could be spoiler.

In the new story "Drama", Triona was mentioned few times.

and also Lia Fail reappears in there. I cannot say more because devCAT made them as a minor NPCS now. unless if you guys do not care if this is a spoiler.