Beach of Scathach - underwater inhabitants

I suggest either a list of underwater inhabitants or a link to a page of the underwater inhabitants, because right now the link goes to sahagin, and they are not the only monsters that spawn (that's one thing I haven't seen spawn at all myself). Other monster spawn if you fish in different areas. There are trolls, for example.

Wait...you can fish a troll o.e? ...well...yeah I think we do need a list.

So far, I've only been fishing up items and the River Sahagins. I have yet to see fishing up other mob types.

The southwestern fishing area was spawning sea trolls.

I also think that the 2 different areas give different things too. I fished in the river for quite some time, and I get things that I didn't get in the troll area. Things like jellyfish and striped marlin were pretty common in the river, but I still haven't caught a either one in the troll spot. There's also stuff in the troll spot that I haven't caught in the river too. Stuff like sunfish, but I know i caught rainbow trouts in both spots. Can anyone else check this out? I caught a bracer knuckle manual in the ocean area, and it might be an ocean thing.

Ok, I was partly wrong, those are sahagin at the river area, they just didn't look like the sahagin I'm familiar with and I was busy running away. So I've had sea trolls in the ocean/southwest area and river sahagin fighers and river sahagin rangers at the river area. I'm going to start keeping track of what areas give what fish/items.

I never get any item when I fish a spawn, so i think it's safe to assume the spawn is the fishing reward, and since they differ based on where you are, that means these two spots have different fishing lists.

Does anyone who got the meditation book remember where it was?

Interesting, can you post more of your findings? Like what kind of items, monsters, etc you found in one and how it differed from the other? (And say where you think the demarcation line is.)

I'm not sure what you mean by "demarcation line".

So far, I've only gotten king crab, golden scale fish and deep-sea fish from the ocean(south/troll) area, and I've only gotten sweetfish and taitinn carp from the river(north/sahagin) area. I've gotten flying fish from both. I've stopped fishing at the north because the south is much safer(slower aggro, slower movement, less frequent attacks, no f***ing teleport, and they only use melee; whereas river rangers seem to triple aggro instantly, and spam teleport and high ranked lightning if i try to run).

Also, during the costume/homestead fishing event, I stayed there for hours and didn't get a single spawn with the event bait.(more evidence that it's part of the fish list rather than a feature of the map)

I've gotten a lot of things on the list at both places, the rates are just really different I think. I got quite a few meditation books and bracer manuals from the ocean though. I'll spend a couple tins at the river and see what happens.

With 300 bait at the river I got: monster: 58, food waste: 16, king crab: 6, golden scale fish: 7, Garbage herb: 19, belvast eel: 19, hp 30: 9, hp 50: 8, mp 30: 9, mp 50: 11, sp 30: 15, sp 50: 8, bracer knuckle manual: 1, taitinn carp: 12, bandage: 7, jellyfish: 16, rainbow trout: 10, sweetfish: 5, striped marlin: 11, deep sea fish: 5 I'm pretty sure I didn't get everything in this batch, but really this is pretty different catches than the ocean area that I usually fish at.

Rank Fishing (Not that it would matter...)

Rank 1 of course. With a normal fishing rod.

With 30 bait at the ocean I got: cor medi book: 1, food waste: 3, sunfish: 1, flying fish: 1, garbage herb: 1, hp 50: 2, monster: 6, rainbow trout: 1, mp 50: 1, sp 30: 2, golden scale fish: 1, ray: 1, reef lobster: 1, hp 30: 1, angler fish: 1, mp 30: 1. This is good enough for me to know they give different things lol. If someone else wants to fill in more stuff go ahead, but I'm done.

Sorry, this is a bit late, but I forgot about it from a long time ago. I fished up all items from both locations. (Of course, that was like 5 months ago and there's a small chance it's changed since then.)